According to new research, the most effective strategy for influencing healthy food choices is not calorie counts and reduced prices, but rather more subtle incentives that reward healthy eating behavior.
Healthy eating advocates have been calling on fast-food restaurants, schools, and food providers to promote the sale of salads and vegetables as alternatives to burgers, fries and other less healthful options.
New research from Cornell University found that perhaps we’ve been going about it the wrong way: instead of telling people to eat better and pushing counting calories and food restrictions, offer long-term reward incentives for healthy eating.
The study, “McHealthy: How Marketing Incentives Influence Healthy Food Choices,” by Robert Kwortnik, associate professor at Cornell’s School of Hotel Administration; Brian Wansink, the John S. Dyson Professor of Marketing in Cornell’s Dyson School of Applied Economics and Management; and Elisa K. Chan of the Ecole hôtelière de Lausanne, was recently accepted for upcoming publication in the Cornell Hospitality Quarterly.
The researchers found that consumers who have poor eating habits and who are overweight benefit the most from long-term reward incentives than if they are offered price reductions of an equal value. However, among healthy eaters, price breaks lead to more purchases of less healthy items.
In one study, a reward-points group of customers was told they would receive 50 points equivalent to 50 cents on a points-collection card redeemable for future purchases if they chose the targeted food item; the price-discount group of customers was told they would receive 50 cents off the price of a specified meal.
The findings are significant because they reveal a positive path – behavioral rewards for making good food choices – to healthy eating, as opposed to the punitive path (e.g., calorie counting or food restrictions). We find that offering rewards, such as points that can be redeemed later, encourage healthy food choices, especially for consumers with bad eating habits. So restaurants can encourage repeat patronage with reward programs and encourage healthy eating by rewarding consumers for making better choices. It’s a win-win.
Behavioral reward programs also introduce more variety, especially among healthy food choices, and consumers are rewarded for making smarter choices.
The study indicates:
…incentivizing with behavioral rewards is more effective for consumers who are either overweight or junk-food junkies. The points received for each healthy choice not only led to a reward (e.g., accumulated cash value or free food), but also signify the otherwise intangible benefits of an isolated act of eating healthy.
For food service providers, healthy eating incentives help build a better brand at a lower cost.
The study said:
While fast-food restaurants spend millions on marketing healthy menu options, these efforts have little effect on consumers’ choices.
Rather than overtly telling consumers to eat better, we propose and show through the empirical results that behavioral reward programs trigger a longer-term view that coincides with longer-term goals to eat healthy versus more immediate goals to indulge in typically less healthy foods such as fries, salty snacks or sweets.
The findings also provide a better solution for governments and policymakers that rely on taxation and regulation to promote healthy eating. While those solutions place undesirable burdens on businesses, “policies or regulations to encourage behavioral rewards programs are unlikely to stimulate negative reactions from food companies because such programs help promote the healthy food items already on their menus and encourage repeat customers.”